SolidarityTools

Plain-English tools for people organising together.

Co-op governance pack

The sections your rules need, one member one vote as a procedure, voting mechanics, officer roles, disputes and the yearly cycle.

Governance is the set of rules that lets a group disagree and still decide — so decisions are made by the members, not by whoever shouts loudest or is best at admin. The test is simple: do the rules protect the quiet members? A group where the confident decide and the quiet find out afterwards has no rules, only habits.

1. Model rules: the sections your rules need

Work down the list and stop when every line is filled in. It is a skeleton, not a template.

Fill in, in this order

The clause that decides what you are. If the surplus is shared among the members on winding up, you have written a private company calling itself a co-operative — the members can sell the assets, split the money and walk away. An asset lock, sending whatever is left on dissolution to another co-operative or to a purpose named in the rules, is what distinguishes a real co-op from a business using the word.

2. One member, one vote is a procedure, not a sentence

One member, one vote is a line in the rules. Making it true is a procedure, and the procedure is what stops a confident minority carrying every meeting.

  1. The proposal goes in writing, circulated with a deadline: what is proposed, who proposes it, the cost, and by when members must reply.
  2. One round of discussion. Everyone who wants to speak speaks once before anyone speaks twice — the rule that protects the quiet member, and the first one groups drop.
  3. Amendments, also in writing, with their own deadline, or the wording gets rewritten by whoever is quickest.
  4. The vote, on the proposal as amended, by the method the rules set out.
  5. The record: what was decided, who is bound, who carries it out, and by when. An unrecorded decision did not happen.

Set the threshold for each kind of decision in the rules. Three kinds cover almost everything.

KindWhat it meansWhat the rules must say
Ordinary decisionMore members vote for than against.Whether abstentions count. Say "of those present and voting", so an abstention is not counted as a no.
Special resolutionRule changes, dissolution, anything else the members decide needs a higher bar.The exact proportion, as a number. A threshold that lives only in habit is no threshold at all.
UnanimousEvery member agrees.Keep the list short, or empty: one member who is away can then stop the group.

Do not leave thresholds to habit. "We usually just agree" holds until the first serious disagreement, when the group finds it has no way to decide.

3. Voting mechanics small groups get wrong

Each of these is a decision in its own right. Settle it once, write it down, and stop arguing about it mid-meeting.

The questionThe rule to write down
Hands or secret ballot?Hands for ordinary business. A ballot whenever the vote could cost someone their place, role or income: expulsion, a sanction, an officer election, a pay decision on one person.
What is an abstention?A member who does not vote either way. Say whether abstentions count. The fair answer: they do not, and a decision passes on a majority of those voting.
What is quorum?The number or proportion who must be present before the meeting can decide anything. Put the number in the rules.
What if quorum fails?Decide now: adjourn to a stated date, and whoever turns up then can decide. Say whether that meeting needs the same quorum.
Proxy, post and online voting?Whether an absent member may vote by proxy, post or online, how it reaches the secretary, and whether it counts towards quorum. A chat message is not a record.
A tied vote?The chair gets no casting vote by default. Better: the proposal fails, is reframed, and returns next meeting. Record the tie and the reason.
Who counts the votes?Two people, neither the subject of the decision nor the proposer. They report the numbers, not just the outcome.

Decisions made outside a meeting. Groups decide things by email or in a chat, which is fine if the decision is ratified. Put the wording and the votes in writing at the time, then list it at the start of the next meeting and ask the members to ratify it as one item. Nobody objects: it is recorded as a decision of the members. Someone objects: it goes through the ordinary procedure.

4. Officer roles in plain English

Officers do the work between meetings. Write a page for each role: what it does, what it decides alone, and what it reports.

The four roles

Handover, before the handover. When an officer steps down, the co-op needs the accounts and bank access, the register and minutes, the passwords, the rules and current filings, and a note of anything outstanding. Hand it over at a meeting, and minute that it happened.

One person holding all three roles is a red flag: whoever calls the meeting, writes the minutes and holds the money is the same person, so no member can check any of it. If you cannot fill three roles, write down what the sole officer must bring to the members, keep two names on the bank mandate, and set a date to fix it.

5. Disputes: agree the process before you need it

A dispute is normal, not a failure. Two members who cannot work together, a decision one member believes was rigged, an officer accused of something: the group that agreed its process in advance handles one in a fortnight, and the group that did not loses members over it.

  1. Agree the process now, while everyone is still friends, and write it into the rules.
  2. Speak to the people involved, directly and in writing, so the concern is read properly rather than heard second hand.
  3. Bring it to the committee with a written summary and the remedy you are seeking. A complaint with no stated remedy can only be punished, never resolved.
  4. Suspend the person from a role, not from the co-op, while it is decided. If the dispute involves power — a treasurer, a chair, anyone controlling money, records or access — step them out for the duration. It protects the process and is fair to the person too.
  5. Offer independent mediation before any sanction: someone from another co-operative, a federation, a union officer, a community mediator. It costs less than the members you would otherwise lose.
  6. Only then a members' vote on a sanction. The person must have been told the complaint, must be able to put their side in writing, and must be able to see the evidence against them. If it could cost them their place or income, vote by secret ballot.
  7. Record the outcome and the reasons: what was alleged, what was decided, why, and what the person may do next. A decision with reasons can be reviewed; one without cannot be defended.

The fairness basics, in three lines. The person must be told the complaint against them. They must get a real chance to answer it. And they must not be judged by anyone with a stake in the outcome — not the person who complained, not the person whose conduct is the subject.

6. The annual cycle

Governance that only happens when something goes wrong is not governance. Shift these months to suit your own year; the order matters more than the dates.

WhenWhat has to happen
Start of the yearSet the budget and the membership fee, decided by the members, before anyone is asked to pay.
Early in the yearFix the date of the annual general meeting and note the notice period your rules require.
Before the annual meetingSend notice to every member within the notice period, with the accounts, the officers' reports, and any rule change or election.
The annual general meetingMembers receive the accounts, elect the officers and the committee, decide the fee, and vote on any rule change.
After the annual meetingFile the annual return and the accounts where your registration route requires it, and update the register of members.
Once a year, a set monthReview the rules against what the group actually does. Rules nobody has read in three years are usually being broken quietly.
On the renewal datesRenew the insurance, and any registration or licence the group holds. Read the date off the policy or certificate, not a website.
Whenever it changesTell the registering body about a change of registered office, officers or name where the rules or the law require it. These are the filings people forget.

Which of these are legal obligations? The annual return, the accounts, and the renewal of a registration or insurance policy come from the law or from a contract: miss them and it costs money, and can put officers personally on the hook. The notice period and the election of officers come from your own rules. The rest is good practice.

The exact dates depend on where you are and how you registered. In Ireland, a co-operative is registered either through the Registrar of Friendly Societies, as a society with co-operative rules, or as a company limited by guarantee. The filing dates, form names and notice periods differ between the two routes, and they change. Check the current requirement with the body you registered with — the Registrar of Friendly Societies, the Companies Registration Office, or ICOS if you adopted its model rules. Do not rely on a date printed online.

Not legal advice. This page does not replace a solicitor, an accountant, ICOS or the body you register with. It is the questions and the structure to take to them.

Related: Starting a worker co-op covers the decisions that come before the rules, and what it costs to register a co-op or a company sets the two Irish routes side by side.

Free to copy, adapt and pass on.